# EDDIE UA – White Paper: Federated Energy Data Access for Ukraine

> **PUBLIC READER COPY OF RESEARCH DRAFT v0.1.** Based on the 20 November 2026 edition. Not adopted NCRECP policy, independent legal advice or EU EDDIE consortium material. Publication approval remains pending.

**Version 0.1 · 20 November 2026 · Initiated by Wesfin Group**
**DRAFT FOR CONSULTATION. Not a governmental programme, endorsed European EDDIE project, certified market platform, or formal Ukrainian bill.**

## Executive summary
Ukraine has already adopted a critical legal principle: Law No. 4834-IX of 7 April 2026, effective on 23 April 2026, introduced Article 53(6) to the Electricity Market Law (No. 2019-VIII), requiring the statutory commercial metering administrator (AKO) to ensure non-discriminatory access by interested parties to consumer data in accordance with the Commercial Metering Code. **The primary reform question is no longer whether to establish that broad principle; it is how to implement enforceable, secure, interoperable and competitively neutral access in practice.**

EDDIE UA proposes a testable **single statutory metering administrator with multiple interoperable technical data-access providers**, subject to clear legal powers, access permissions and neutral oversight. It is an optional architectural model, not a requirement to establish multiple statutory administrators. The less complex alternative of a centrally managed open API with geographically redundant infrastructure must remain a credible comparator.

## 1. Why electricity data access matters
Industrial consumers, aggregators, flexible loads, BESS operators, energy communities and efficiency services need verified interval metering data, a stable metering point identifier, correction events and a lawful method to authorise third-party use. Inconsistent interfaces and unclear accountabilities may increase integration costs, but these are **hypotheses to measure**, not independently proven violations by Ukraine's existing AKO or market infrastructure.

Neither federation nor decentralisation automatically makes a system cheaper or more resilient. A shared national directory may itself be a single point of failure, and multiple operators increase the burden of certification and coordinated security.

## 2. Ukraine's actual legal baseline
The Electricity Market Law Art.53 retains statutory AKO responsibilities. Art.53(6), added by Law 4834-IX in April 2026, already refers to non-discriminatory access to consumption and commercial metering data as well as data needed to change a supplier/aggregator or provide demand response, subject to the Commercial Metering Code and monitoring by the regulator.

The Commercial Metering Code (NCRECP Resolution No.311 of 14 March 2018) already contains obligations involving authorised access to master data, technical ability to transfer metering data to entitled parties, a metering point and EIC registry, data validation, confidentiality, preservation of changes and corrections. Consequently, a future regulatory initiative should **map and remedy precise procedural gaps**, not duplicate existing statutory rights.

Legal status of independently operated access and permission services remains a matter for counsel and the competent authority. An EIC number alone is not proof of a customer's right to receive a particular data series.

## 3. European policy reference
Directive (EU) 2019/944 Articles 17, 23 and 24 cover independent aggregation, secure and non-discriminatory data access and interoperability. Article 23(5) also addresses customer charges and justified eligible-party access fees. Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2023/1162 establishes a reference model comprising functional roles including metered data administrator, metering point administrator, data access provider, permission administrator and eligible party. It describes six procedures for: customer access; third-party access; end of service; permission revocation; near-real-time smart meter activation; and near-real-time reading.

EU law does not prescribe a DNS-like federation or require several statutory AKOs. Direct application and transposition obligations in Ukraine, including obligations under Energy Community acquis, need separate legal analysis. An engineered resemblance to European roles is not a legal compliance certificate.

## 4. Architecture and separation of duties
A metering point authority directory resolves an EIC to the currently responsible technical source and an effective authority epoch. This is DNS-inspired discovery, not DNS name hierarchy. Identity and rights services verify a company's legal representative and the correct metering-point relationship; knowledge of EIC and registration number alone is insufficient.

A permission service records legal basis, recipient, permitted categories, purpose, period, grant, revocation and invalidation. A standard gateway enforces access rules and provides a customer-accessible audit log. Data nodes provide provenance, interval, quality, version, time zone and correction lineage. A controlled transfer protects the authority epoch and synchronises history with verifiable evidence.

The official metering and imbalance settlement framework remains solely with the legally competent organisations. DataHub is not a real-time battery dispatch control plane. Wesfin Edge retains local industrial safety and control functions independent of this data access architecture.

## 5. Engineering evidence and its limitations
Wesfin Group's GitHub proof-of-concept track has in-memory synthetic authority, separate local HTTP/SQLite processes, directory-coordinated epoch fencing and durable pending-operation recovery. GitHub Actions reports passing synthetic jobs for PRs #7, #9 and #11 on their audited commit SHAs. The initial independent run for PR #6 failed before jobs started and must not be reported as successful.

This is meaningful software evidence but **not proof of production split-brain safety, cryptographic trust among organisations, official settlement correctness, Ukrainian accreditation or conformity to EU Regulation 2023/1162**. The next engineering tasks are independent PKI, signed node receipts, network partition and recovery testing, replicated authority coordination, tested identity and a neutral conformance suite.

## 6. A consumer-to-aggregator demonstration
For a synthetic industrial consumer, the demonstrator should show: verification of legal representation; granting a time- and purpose-scoped permission for a metering point; the eligible party reading versioned interval measurements; a simulated flexibility study; a visible audit; customer revocation; correction of a historical interval; and movement of technical responsibility from node A to node B without silently changing the consumer's BRP, supplier or statutory settlement.

The demonstration is about a consumer journey, not simply HTTP connectivity. Before introducing real metering points or customer data, lawful authority, agreements, privacy and security approvals are required.

## 7. Neutral governance
Wesfin Group may sponsor research and build software; Wesfin Flex must be an eligible party on the same published terms as its competitors. Legal oversight must be exercised only by authorised institutions. Technical admission should be independently reviewed, documented, contestable and based on the same tests for all providers. Operators must not exploit access to confidential consumer data for competing trading or sales businesses without a lawful basis.

## 8. Economic decision framework
Compare A – open centrally operated API plus geo-redundancy; B – one AKO with independent certified access nodes; and C – several AKOs. Consider five-year discounted total cost, capital and operating expenditure, onboarding and integration costs, cybersecurity, monitoring and certification, loss-of-availability risk and benefits demonstrated by real use. Conservative, base and optimistic scenarios should be driven by sourced inputs. No fabricated savings should appear in external communications. Select B only if actual evidence shows sufficient benefit over A.

## 9. Roadmap
R0: update legal baseline and publish a reviewed consultation paper. R1: map every relevant EU procedure and Ukrainian rule to test evidence. R2: strengthen the synthetic prototype and independently test failures and security. R3: negotiate a limited lawful market pilot. R4: independently assess regulatory impact and final normative drafting. R5: scale only after appropriate institutional approval and demonstrated service neutrality.

## 10. Open consultation
We invite NCRECP, Ukrenergo/AKO, metering service providers, distribution operators, BRPs, suppliers, independent aggregators, industrial consumers, lawmakers and European researchers to challenge this proposal. These organisations are addressees for possible consultation, **not existing partners or endorsers**.


## Why energy-data infrastructure matters to the next electricity market

Ukraine's electricity market is changing through distributed solar, battery storage, EV charging, industrial flexibility and behind-the-meter energy systems. The economics of these resources depend on trustworthy interval consumption and export history, legal access rights, quality markers and corrected versions.

A factory with a short 500 kW peak does not necessarily need a 500 kW battery. Part of the peak may come from a movable process or avoidable simultaneous equipment starts. Proper historical analysis can reduce investment mistakes. But a permission to read data does not authorise a control command over that factory's equipment.

The value of an access infrastructure therefore lies in enabling neutral, lawful and reliable decisions while preserving the integrity of official metering records.

## An intellectual reference to the European EDDIE project

The name EDDIE UA references the subject matter of the Horizon Europe research project European Distributed Data Infrastructure for Energy, active in 2023–2026. The European initiative researched a common access layer over national data infrastructures, with the EDDIE Framework, on-site AIIDA and a Data Services Marketplace.

EDDIE UA is an independent Wesfin Group initiative focused on Ukrainian legislation, market parties and implementation choices. It is not an official branch, franchise or grant beneficiary of European EDDIE. We do not claim endorsement or automatic rights to its name or mark, and we must independently evaluate brand confusion and possible trademark issues. See the [full European EDDIE and naming article](?page=european-eddie).

## A complete industrial-customer scenario

Consider a food-processing plant with flexible refrigeration, an existing supplier and a third-party balancing responsible party. The plant wants an independent aggregator to evaluate whether shifting a few operating cycles creates economic value. The aggregator needs validated historical measurements but does not yet need control over the refrigeration equipment.

The intended information workflow first establishes the customer and its legal representative, verifies its relationship to the EIC/metering point, determines the processing basis, recipient, purpose and historical scope, and retrieves only properly authorised data. Each interval carries its quality and revision information. The aggregator analyses flexibility and presents options to the customer.

A later decision to purchase battery storage or implement demand response requires separate investment analysis, degradation costs, market contracts, site engineering, metering and operational safety. The information-access grant cannot silently create those rights.

## One authoritative settlement record does not rule out interoperable services

A technical federation need not imply multiple statutory commercial metering administrators. Under the research concept, Ukraine's legally competent organisations continue to determine official commercial metering data, while interoperable technical providers may carry out defined information access functions where the law permits.

This design needs trustworthy provenance, versions, monotonic authority epochs and a recoverable audit trail. Two nodes must not simultaneously create contradictory confirmed authorities after a handover. An unavailable permissions directory cannot justify indiscriminate disclosure. Our synthetic prototypes test only part of that problem; independent keys, networks and qualified security assurance remain future work.

## Customer rights, other lawful bases and privacy

A customer should be able to understand who is entitled to what data, for which purpose and time period, with appropriate access-history visibility and withdrawal procedures. But not every legitimate processing activity is based solely on consent. Separate statutory or contractual obligations must be considered. Open technical standards must not be confused with unrestricted public consumption profiles.

## Competing architectures and measurable costs

A central, open and geographically redundant API with one AKO may be simpler and cheaper than a federation. A legally permitted multi-node information layer may offer more flexibility but adds trust management, operator audits and recovery complexity. Multiple statutory AKOs represent a separate and much more complex legal reform.

Five-year cost analysis must include design, integration, security, operations, legal compliance, support and realistic fault impacts. Benefits should be measured through onboarding, integration expense, quality, availability and actual services enabled. Trading gross revenue and unverified savings percentages are not suitable substitutes for an evidence-based assessment.

## What would make EDDIE UA genuinely credible

Independent technical conformance, verified legal entitlements, secure and auditable data processing, externally reviewed network resilience, a measured economic comparison and a lawful pilot with competent market parties. Depending on results, a central API, federated access services or a hybrid arrangement may be preferable.

The purpose of the initiative is to test this claim, not to make a particular network architecture or commercial vendor inevitable.


### Primary sources
1. Ukraine Law 4834-IX: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/4834-20
2. Electricity Market Law 2019-VIII: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2019-19
3. Commercial Metering Code 311: https://www.nerc.gov.ua/acts/pro-zatverdzhennya-kodeksu-komertsiynogo-obliku-elektrichnoi-energii
4. Directive 2019/944 consolidated: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dir/2019/944/2025-10-12
5. Implementing Regulation 2023/1162: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg_impl/2023/1162/oj/eng
6. European EDDIE research architecture: https://architecture.eddie.energy/

**Independence and publication gate:** EDDIE UA is an independent Wesfin Group initiative, not an official partner or representative of the European EDDIE consortium. Name/mark and legal review plus owner approval are required before public promotion.
